I’m not usually the type to brag about something I made with my own two hands. I tend to keep my head down, do the work, and let things be what they are. But every once in a while, something turns out so unexpectedly good that staying quiet feels almost dishonest.
This was one of those days.
It started like most of my quieter days do—no big plans, no rush, just that familiar itch to be outside and do something real. The kind of something that smells like earth and leaves and effort. The woods were calm, the air cool enough to wake you up without biting, and the trees stood there like they always do, minding their own business.
That’s when I noticed the shagbark hickory.
If you’ve ever seen one up close, you know why it gets that name. The bark peels away in long, curling strips, rough and textured, like the tree itself is shrugging off old layers. It’s not a flashy tree. It doesn’t demand attention. But it has character. And as it turns out, flavor.
I’d heard people talk about making syrup from shagbark hickory bark. Not sap—bark. The idea sounded strange the first time I heard it. Tree bark doesn’t exactly scream “sweet treat.” But curiosity has always been one of my biggest weaknesses, and once that seed was planted, I couldn’t let it go.
So I decided: today’s the day.
I gathered fallen pieces of bark—important detail there, because this isn’t about harming a living tree. It’s about using what nature has already let go of. The bark smelled incredible even before anything else happened. Smoky. Warm. Almost like a campfire mixed with vanilla and rain-soaked wood.
Back home, the process was slow and simple. No fancy tools. No rushing. Just bark, water, heat, and patience.
As the bark simmered, the kitchen filled with a smell that stopped me in my tracks. It wasn’t sharp like sugar. It wasn’t bright like maple. It was deep. Comforting. The kind of smell that makes you think of old cabins, wool blankets, and stories told by firelight.
I remember standing there thinking, If it tastes half as good as it smells, I’ll be happy.
Turns out, that was a massive understatement.
When the liquid darkened and thickened, turning into something syrupy and rich, I took the smallest taste. Just enough to know.
And that was it.
Game over.
This wasn’t just “good for something homemade.” This was genuinely incredible. Woodsy in the best way. Warm without being heavy. Smoky without being bitter. Sweet, but not loud about it. It didn’t punch you in the mouth with sugar—it wrapped around you slowly, like it wanted you to pay attention.
I actually laughed out loud.
Then I did something I didn’t expect at all: I compared it to maple syrup in my head—and maple didn’t win.
That felt almost wrong to admit. Maple syrup is practically sacred. It’s the gold standard. The thing everything else gets compared to. But this? This was different. Not better in a competitive way, but better in a this speaks to me way.
It felt older. Quieter. Like a flavor that doesn’t need to prove anything.
continued on next page
