- The Prep: Slice the tomato into thick, 1/2-inch rounds. Using thick slices ensures a chef’s kiss meaty texture.
- The Spread: Generously spread mayonnaise (or softened butter) on both slices of bread, edge-to-edge. This creates a barrier so the bread doesn’t get soggy too fast.
- The Seasoning: Place the tomato slices on one piece of bread. Sprinkle generously with salt and black pepper. If using, drizzle a tiny bit of olive oil now.
- The Wait: Wait one minute. This allows the salt to start the “sauce” process.
- The Close: Top with the second slice of bread and press down gently to “marry” the flavors.
- The Serve: Cut diagonally for a classy look and eat immediately over a plate to catch the drips!
Serving and Storage: The Immediate Reward
How to Serve
Serve fresh! This is soooo good with a side of kettle-cooked potato chips or a cold glass of iced tea. For a classy look, add a leaf of fresh basil or a sprig of dill.
Storage Tips
A tomato sandwich waits for no one! It is soooo good only when eaten immediately. Do not refrigerate or save for later, as the bread will lose its structural “regulations” and become mushy. It’s a weeknight rescue meant for the moment!
Tips: The “Tomato Temperature” Regulation
Never use a cold tomato! Refrigeration kills the flavor enzymes in a tomato. For a soooo good experience, use a room-temperature tomato fresh from the counter. It will be sweeter, juicier, and have a much more classy look when sliced.
Variations: Flipping the Slices
- The Caprese Twist: Add a slice of fresh mozzarella and a drizzle of balsamic glaze for a chef’s kiss Italian vibe.
- The Southern Kick: Use Duke’s Mayo and add a dash of hot sauce to the tomato for a soooo good zesty bite.
- The Toasted Treat: Lightly toast the bread for extra crunch and a more classy look.
Conclusion: Perfection in a Pair
The Tomato Sandwich is proof that the best things in life are simple. It’s a weeknight rescue that delivers a classy look and a chef’s kiss flavor with almost zero effort. Once you taste a high-quality tomato with just salt and mayo, you’ll realize why this soooo good classic is a summertime religion for many. Enjoy the juice!
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best bread?
While many prefer soft white bread for its nostalgia, a sturdy sourdough is a chef’s kiss choice because it holds up better to the heavy tomato juices.
Can I use cherry tomatoes?
You can, but they tend to roll out of the sandwich! Large slices follow the “regulations” for a classy look and easier eating.
Why mayo instead of butter?
Mayo has a slight tang and acidity that “regulates” the sweetness of the tomato, making it soooo good, but butter is a great creamy alternativ
